New Who Review: The Rebel Flesh, The Almost People, and A Good Man Goes to War
Posted By Kathleen David on June 6, 2011
This is a chunk of New Who to Review but honestly I think it is better to look at this as a piece. The Rebel Flesh and the Almost People were a two parter but considering what happens at the end of the Almost People, it needs to be done as a block.
I got to the end of these three and thought, “Moffat, you magnificent bášŧárd. You have my attention for the second half of the season for sure.” We have answers to things from last season that seemed to be throw aways at the time. We have a number of answers for the first part of the season. And we have yet more questions. As Peter said, this is going to be one of those seasons that you sit down one evening and marathon to see all the threads that were created.
Acting is solid all the way around. Arthur Darville is making Rory a new favorite companion in my book. Matt Smith gets to play around with some other emotions and reactions that shows he has a big range than they had originally given the Doctor (more about that in the spoiler section). Karen Gillian was given some really tough stuff to play around with this season and she did a great job.
This was good Who with all the monsters and morality you could shake a stick at.
I am grateful for the first half of this season and looking forward to the second half.
Behind the cut is going to be both my thoughts an a little speculation about the second half. I ask the comments stick to the first half of this season and only your own speculation. I don’t want/need spoilers. I accidently got one for A Good Man Goes to War and it took the punch out of something. If you haven’t seen the episodes I am talking about well here there be spoilers but I am breaking it into two pieces with a break in between because A Good Man Goes to War hasn’t been shown in the US